Case study · Spring 2023

A reusable cup, and a better reason to take a break

With a team in the Talent Garden master, we designed an app concept for Cicara's smart cup: fifty interviews, then a prototype tested again and again.

Cicara Time Out

www.cicara.it

An app concept for Cicara, the smart reusable cup for vending machines: pay with the cup, earn cashback, gift a coffee and protect your break.

Role
UX research and UI design
My part
Interviews, personas, ideation, flows, wireframes, high-fidelity UI and tests, with the team
Team
Design team of the Talent Garden master, brief by Cicara
Timeline
Spring 2023
Platform
iOS app concept
Tools
Figma, Miro, pen and paper

Problem

Cicara makes a smart, reusable cup for vending machines, and needed a service that makes people want to use it.

Decision

Design around the break itself: pay with the cup, reward reuse, protect the pause and share it.

What shipped

A high-fidelity iOS prototype with ten key features.

What changed

Dozens of quick usability tests reshaped the gift flow and the dashboard, and added clear confirmations.

What I take with me

A coffee break looks simple, but everyone lives it differently: designing for all of them is the real work.

The product

The product, first

Moving screens from the high-fidelity prototype.

Feeling A seamless onboarding, from one screen to the next.
Connect the cup Bring the phone close to the cup and they pair at once; then the cup pays on its own at cafés and vending machines.
Take a break In a break the app turns calmer, shows only the essentials and suggests a short mindfulness exercise.

The brief

A smart cup looking for a reason to be used

Cicara is an Italian company that wants to replace the disposable cups of vending machines with a smart, eco-friendly cup, with a 100% biodegradable cover you can swap to your taste.

The Cicara cup on a desk
The Cicara cup. Photo: Cicara.

The brief asked us to design a new service born from the relationship between the cup and the machines around it, one that makes people use it and feel more connected, more sustainable and part of a community.

  1. Research

    The context: the vending supply chain and the NFC sensor in the cup.

  2. Define

    Insights and personas from the interviews.

  3. Identify

    Opportunities and solutions.

  4. Create

    The UX flows and a high-fidelity UI.

  5. Iterate

    Through test feedback, again and again.

DiscoverResearch

Fifty conversations about a coffee break

We studied the context and the competitors, direct and indirect. Then we went to the people, because a break, like a coffee, means something different to everyone.

50interviews, with people of different ages, regions and lifestyles
2settings compared in every answer: at the office and away from it

What we wanted to understand

  1. An enjoyable break

    How to make the break a moment people enjoy.

  2. Sustainability in practice

    How people see sustainability, and what they actually do.

  3. Design and brands

    Which design and brands people prefer, and why.

  4. Coffee break habits

    How the coffee break fits into people's days.

The questions stayed open, so people could talk about their own relationship with the break. We held the interviews during the break itself, to catch real emotions and what people don't say.

Question 1

What does taking a break mean to you, at work or away from it?

Alone

  • Rest
  • A break means finding the energy to come back fresher
  • Sometimes I put my headphones on so nobody disturbs me
  • Take some time for myself
  • Watch a film
  • I don't see the break as an excuse for small talk

Switching off

  • Switch off and stop thinking about work
  • Shut the laptop
  • Clear my head after a stretch of focus
  • A break is an interlude between tasks
  • Eat something
  • Relax

With others

  • Chat
  • At work, a break means a quick call to a friend or family
  • Chat with a colleague
  • Play chess
  • Ping pong
  • Coffee while I watch the kids

Notes from our interview board, translated from Italian. Every answer was also split between the office and away from it.

The interview board: one column per research objective, answers grouped on sticky notes
The full interview board: one column per objective, office and away from it side by side.

DefinePersonas and insights

People don't really get to take a break

Coding the interviews showed that people live their breaks in far from ideal conditions: some work too much to make time for themselves, others are always interrupted by calls and problems.

Four personas

Portrait of the persona Bianca Montanaro

Bianca Montanaro, 26

Ski instructor · Madonna di Campiglio

It’s lovely to start the day sharing a good coffee with my colleagues. It gives me the right energy for a day on the snow.

What drives them

  • Coffee with her colleagues before work, taking turns to offer it
  • Vegetarian, she tries to keep her impact on the environment low
  • Inspired by athletes and by people who protect the mountains

What gets in the way

  • Eight hours in a row on the slopes, with no rest until 5 pm
  • Little flexibility in her shifts
  • Struggles to balance work and personal life
  • Few vegetarian or vegan options at the ski resort
Portrait of the persona Francesco Scriba

Francesco Scriba, 29

Copywriter at a startup · Commutes from Turin to Milan

I don’t see coffee as a vice, but as a treat. Not a duty, something I look for.

What drives them

  • Wants to spend quality time with his colleagues
  • Loves other people’s stories: sharing something personal is how you get close
  • Curious, he notices new details on his way to work every day

What gets in the way

  • Four months in, he still hasn’t bonded with his colleagues
  • Smart working, no shared spaces and staggered hours leave few chances to meet
  • Often spends his breaks alone at the computer, and hates when work interrupts them
  • Always running for the train, with no time for breakfast
Portrait of the persona Beatrice Zen

Beatrice Zen, 50

Freelance psychotherapist · Savona

I’m learning to allow myself to feel tired. You have to plan your breaks.

What drives them

  • Plans her breaks before fatigue turns into stress
  • Coffee is a ritual of sharing
  • Needs to stay in touch with her body and her emotions
  • Recycles at home, but rarely checks if her favourite brands are sustainable

What gets in the way

  • Her breaks get ruined by people who disturb her
  • Mismatched appointments stop her from chatting with a colleague
  • A call from the bank or an email can take over her break
Portrait of the persona Simone Presabene

Simone Presabene, 42

Digital transformation manager · Rome

For me, it all comes down to being moved, and sharing it.

What drives them

  • Creates moments of exchange that keep his team’s work human
  • Coffee at the machine with his team puts him in a good mood
  • Wants to feel more useful to his community

What gets in the way

  • Always in a rush, he can’t enjoy the special moments of his day
  • Often fails to protect his own breaks and his team’s
  • Being always connected makes him anxious, even before work starts
  • So much work that he ends up eating at his desk

Composite personas from the interviews, each with an experience map of a whole day.

positivenegativeWake upCommuteRitualPatientsBreakHomeDay offcoffeereadingtea ritualpatientscallsmusicgarden

Redrawn from Beatrice's experience map: her day is full of small rituals, and the break is the lowest point, broken by a call from the bank and an email.

  • Recharging in progress A routine with regular breaks helps people manage their commitments and restart with more energy.
  • I wish, but I can't Protecting the break from interruptions, and sometimes from ourselves, feels nearly impossible and leaves people more tired than before.
  • You offer or I offer? Offering a coffee is a small, kind gesture that becomes a chance to come together.
  • From one thing comes another The coffee ritual crosses generations and situations, and keeps creating new rituals around sharing.

IdeateWorkshops

Two questions, hundreds of ideas

From the insights we wrote the right questions, then answered them with hundreds of ideas, using Crazy 8 and group round robin.

How might we…: …help people plan their breaks and protect them?

What we designed: An app that helps you balance productivity and real downtime, a partner in crime against interruptions.

How might we…: …make buying a coffee seamless and engaging?

What we designed: A digital wallet with sustainable cashback, rewards and games in Cicara's style.

Part of the ideation board with sticky notes
Part of the ideation board, from the round robin sessions.

DesignInteraction design

Five flows, tested before they looked good

We started from the main flows, then built medium-fidelity wireframes to run the first usability tests and fix flows and screens quickly.

The app, tab by tab

  1. Cicara app
  1. Board
  2. Gifted coffees
  3. Available credit
  4. Cups saved
  5. Caffeine tracking
  6. History
  7. Often offered
  8. Offer to a friend
  9. Pay
  1. Diary
  2. Create a team
  3. Add contentphotos, videos, places, music
  1. Activities
  2. Timer
  1. Profile
  2. Your CicarasTalent, home, office, emergency
  3. Add a Cicara
  4. Settingspayment, privacy, diary, general, support
The information architecture from our Figma file (2023), translated from Italian.

The five main flows

  • Pay for your own coffee.
  • Offer a coffee to a friend, or challenge them.
  • See the feed shared with your team.
  • Start a new activity, with a pomodoro timer.
  • Enter a break and keep track of your breaks.
Medium-fidelity wireframes of the Cicara app
Onboarding, login, then connecting the wallet, the cup and Apple Health.

For the high fidelity we made a mood board and followed Cicara's brand book, with SF Pro Display and SF Pro Text.

DesignHigh fidelity

Pay with the cup, gift a coffee, protect the break

Gamification The onboarding shows the main features, including challenging a friend to offer a coffee.
Wallet and NFC Pay with your phone, or with the sensor built into the Cicara cup.
Cashback No disposable cup to pay for: every 50 uses earns a cashback reward.
Health Connect Apple Health to follow your daily caffeine and get reminders to take breaks.
Dashboard
Dashboard Your balance, gifts received, coffees drunk, and a quick way to offer one to a friend.
Collect gifts Gifts arrive as cards with a message from the sender.
Give a coffee Personalise the card with your own greeting.
Timers and activities Pomodoro activities synced with your team; at the end, everyone gets a nudge to take a short break.

TestUsability tests

Dozens of quick tests, three big changes

We ran dozens of agile usability tests and tried changes straight away. After a few rounds, the purpose of every screen and flow was clear to everyone. We changed the flow for offering a coffee, redesigned the dashboard and added confirmation and success messages.

Cashback
Cashback An indicator and badges to follow your cashback.
Overview
Overview Before the mini-game, a summary confirms the friend you chose.
New activity
New activity Redesigned to feel like the phone's own apps, so the steps are easier to follow.
Welcome
Welcome Activities and Diary open with a short guide to their main features.
Challenge a friend
Challenge a friend People first struggled with the dice and with telling "offer" from "play": an uncommon pattern in apps.

Reflection

Looking back

What I take with me

Breaks and coffee look simple, but they involve everyone, and a flow that fits everyone is nearly impossible. We tried to make Cicara an app anyone could use: in a company or freelance, alone or in a group, quiet or social.