Case study · Summer 2024

Before designing a green energy offer, I asked why switching feels so hard

I ran the UX research for Click To Green, a new renewable energy provider: market data, competitors, a survey and interviews, then the flow and the KPIs.

Click To Green

clicktogreen.it

Renewable electricity from FERA's wind farms, sold directly to people and businesses.

Role
UX research and flow design
My part
Desk and data research, benchmark, survey, interviews, personas, flows, wireframes, KPIs
Team
Click To Green team; UI designers took the research into the interface
Timeline
Summer 2024
Platform
Website and web app
Tools
Figma, FigJam, Typeform

Problem

Choosing an energy provider is stressful: too many offers, technical jargon, bills that differ from what people expected.

Decision

Read the market and the people first, then design a short flow in plain language.

What shipped

Six insights, four personas, the new-contract flow, low-fi wireframes and a KPI plan, handed to the UI designers.

What I take with me

In a market this technical, the thing to design for is the stress of choosing, as much as the price.

The brief

A new green energy provider

Click To Green sells renewable electricity from FERA's wind farms directly to consumers, and wants to become a reference in green energy. I came in with little knowledge of the field, so I started from the questions.

  • Is there a demand, and is it really needed?
  • What is the state of the market, and what do recent years say?
  • Are there regional differences across Italy?
  • Who is the right audience, and how do we reach them?
  • Can this market really change, or do others already offer the best?

DiscoverDesk research

Read the market before meeting people

I gathered every relevant study I could find online, then went into the raw data.

Sources

  • YouGov
  • Nielsen
  • IEA
  • Sole 24 Ore
  • BloombergNEF
  • Eurostat
  • Istat
  • Statista
  • ARERA

On ARERA's public site I downloaded dozens of Excel files, hundreds of thousands of data points, like how often people change supplier in every Italian municipality, and turned them into charts.

What the data said

  • Renewable energy is growing fast, in Italy too.
  • People switch supplier more and more often: the market is fluid.
  • Fixed prices are still the majority, with a slight shift towards variable ones.
  • The number of offers is at a record: a healthy market, and a confusing one.
  • Many Italians are willing to pay a little more to do their part.

Italians back renewables more than other Europeans

Would back a policy allowing only renewable energyWould switch to a provider using only renewable energy

  • ItalyWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 80%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 62%
  • SpainWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 75%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 66%
  • DenmarkWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 60%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 44%
  • Great BritainWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 58%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 48%
  • SwedenWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 57%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 39%
  • FranceWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 56%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 48%
  • GermanyWould back a policy allowing only renewable energy: 53%Would switch to a provider using only renewable energy: 32%
YouGov, 5–19 April 2022, share of respondents per country. One of the studies in my desk research.

To estimate customers and age groups I cross-checked web research with several AI models, asking the same question with different prompts to spot made-up answers.

DiscoverBenchmark

Is price the only thing people compare?

I went through more than 15 competitors: their services, the new-contract flow, how clear prices and offers are, support and accessibility.

15+competitors analysed: services, flows, prices, support, accessibility
3semiotic maps: brand, marketing and user experience

Steps from the home page to a signed contract

  • Octopus Energy4 steps
  • Limeon6 steps
  • Pulsee10 steps
  • ènostra12 steps
  • Tate16 steps
  • Sorgenia17 steps

Click To Green, proposed 4 steps, like the shortest

Counted on each provider's website, summer 2024.

The user experience map, redrawn: only Octopus Energy was both fast and intuitive. The ring is where Click To Green wanted to be.

PUNCGVF1 · F2 · F0

Jargon that headed whole sections of the sites. I had to look it up elsewhere, and wondered whether everyone felt as lost.

  • Duplicate pages and messy navigation, for people who only want to know which offer suits them and what they will pay.
  • Some flows stop after more than 10 steps, to have you contacted by email or phone.
  • Light text on backgrounds that are not dark enough, even on buttons; small serif type.

DiscoverUser research

Ask people, in their own words

With a small budget, I chose a Typeform survey shared on social media and one-to-one interviews with private customers and businesses.

92%

of people finished the survey in under three and a half minutes

  • Adaptive: one path for private customers, one for businesses
  • An inclusive tone, and room for a comment on every question
  • Shared on social media, to fit a small budget

Then I asked people about the last time they switched provider: memories, emotions, stories. It confirmed the first hypotheses and showed clear patterns.

DefinePersonas

Four people, one journey

Four personas with different goals and needs, and a single journey, because the emotional steps were the same for all of them.

Portrait of the persona Valerio

Valerio, 31

Freelance · Rents in Milan

What drives them

  • Cares about sustainability
  • Watches his budget, but will pay extra for sustainable energy
  • Often browses online for better deals

What gets in the way

  • Wants targeted tips to save with his appliances
  • Often finds bills that don't match what he expected, and struggles to see why
  • Wants to track his consumption to keep himself in check
  • Wants to manage everything from his phone
Portrait of the persona Amelia

Amelia, 27

Office worker · Rents in Genoa

What drives them

  • Cares about sustainability
  • Careful with money
  • At ease on social media, but lost on sites she doesn't know

What gets in the way

  • Wants to do her part for a more sustainable future
  • Doesn't have the tools to compare energy offers
  • Often feels scared and confused, and asks her parents for advice
Portrait of the persona Giorgio

Giorgio, 45

Doctor · Has an office in Savona

What drives them

  • Sustainability is a plus, not a must
  • A very busy life, with little free time
  • Looks for the solution that fits his needs best
  • Careful with money: when he has time, he studies his bills to see what he pays for

What gets in the way

  • No time to compare all the offers
  • Let down by past providers, he has lost trust in energy companies
  • During COVID he got very high bills, even with the office empty
  • Wants a provider that gives him honest advice
Portrait of the persona Clarissa

Clarissa, 41

Manager · Owns her home in Milan

What drives them

  • Cares about sustainability
  • Often gives to ethical causes and is close to LGBTQ+ issues
  • Happy to spend more on a product, if the brand is transparent and ethical

What gets in the way

  • Wants to know where her electricity comes from
  • Wants useful tips to lower her energy footprint
  • Finds online contracts hard to read
  • Put off by offers that are not explained clearly

Composite personas built from the survey and the interviews. Their portraits were generated with AI.

positivenegativeSearchOffersCompareSignDocumentsDoneJoyFearAngerSatisfiedAnnoyedSatisfied

Redrawn from the 2024 journey map: the two dips, comparing offers and finding the documents, were the pain points to solve.

People feel lost when they look for an offer and try to understand it. There are too many, the jargon makes it stressful, and nobody knows what the bill will really be, so these companies look unclear on purpose, or even dishonest.

DefineInsights

Six things people told us

  • Choosing is complicated Every change of provider is stressful: too many offers, hard to read, and the fear of being taken advantage of.
  • Sustainability matters People will pay more for clean energy, as long as the price stays competitive.
  • People want control An app to follow consumption, pay bills, get alerts and tips for each appliance.
  • No to jargon People spend hours learning how a contract works to protect themselves, and still struggle with the terms.
  • Bills are unpredictable What people pay often differs from what they expected.
  • Green as identity Business owners want to tell their clients about it, even if cutting their footprint is not the top priority.

IdeateDecision

From what people said to what to design

What people said: Choosing is complicated.

What to design: A fast flow with only the required fields, and ways to sign up even without the bill at hand.

What people said: No to jargon.

What to design: Plain words at first contact; the technical details in their own section.

What people said: Bills are unpredictable.

What to design: A bill simulator: pick people and appliances, get an all-inclusive estimate with VAT.

What people said: People want control.

What to design: A web app to follow consumption and get advice, and a native app later.

DesignInteraction design

Four steps to a contract, and the email first

The new-contract flow takes four steps, like the shortest competitor, asks only for the essentials and never loses what people typed.

  • Email first Asked and validated at the start, so progress is saved if people stop halfway.
  • Only the essentials The required details now; the secondary ones later.
  • Account in one step After the contract, people leave or set a password and get an account.

Five flows in the site

  1. Home

New contract

  1. Step 1
  2. Step 2
  3. Step 3
  4. Step 4
  5. Done

Offers

  1. Offers
  2. Bill simulator

About

  1. Wind energy
  2. Our effort
  3. Tips

Customer area

  1. Login
  2. Usage
  3. Payments
  4. Contract

Support

  1. Help
Redrawn from the 2024 site map. The new contract is four steps from any page, like the shortest competitor.

Low-fidelity wireframes came next, then the research went to the UI designers.

TestTests and KPIs

Decide how to measure it before it exists

To validate the design I set up tests and KPIs for the next rounds of research.

Before development: test

  1. Research
  2. Solution
  3. Design
  4. Test

until the proposal is clear

After launch: measure

  1. Research
  2. Solution
  3. Design
  4. Development
  5. Product
  6. KPIs

back to research

Before development

Proposal clarity test

Several contract proposals tested against each other before development, to save design time.

After launch

Step completion

The completion rate of each step, to find the one that makes people give up, and fix that one first.

After launch

Time to sign

If the average goes above 7 to 10 minutes, people are struggling to read the steps.

After launch

Call to action

Which button convinces people, and on which page: there is one on every page of the site.

The animations show how each measure reads, not real data: the KPIs were planned before launch.

Reflection

Looking back

What I take with me

Electricity is still sold with an old mindset, while people have new needs. Learning a field from zero and handing the research to the UI designers was a big responsibility, and research is where a simpler product starts.